I’d never been to Santa Fe, New Mexico, and yet it felt like home. The buildings and people were unfamiliar to my eyes but oddly recognizable to my senses. I felt like a local and looked like a one. Tourists stopped and asked for directions or recommendations for a restaurant or hot spot. Even though I’d only been there a week, my response to each request contained an air of confidence.
When I first walked into the Coyote Cafe and Cantina, they welcomed me back. Maybe it was nothing, just their way of making everyone feel comfortable, but it seemed like more.
The waitress approached my table and asked as if I was a regular customer. “Do you want the usual?”
Without even thinking I answered. “Yes” The drink menu lay open on the table, their special, the Coyote Margarita was called “The Usual,” which explained a lot. My imagination was working overtime and made me chuckle at myself.
While looking over the menu, a stranger walked over to me. He stopped and smiled then stuck out his hand. “John, where have you been? It’s been ages.”
I took his hand, not because he was familiar but because my name was John. “Working . . . I’ve been busy.” I stared at him trying to find something familiar about his face. Nothing . . . nothing came to mind.
“You need to come to Milo’s tonight. The whole gang will be there.”
Still bewildered I said, “Thanks, I’ll think about it.”
“I reserved a room from seven to midnight. Tell them you’re with Tony. They all know me.”
“Thanks, Tony, I’ll try to make it. What are you celebrating?”
“It’s something we started last year, a tribute to Aly-Cat and her inspiring spirit. Of course, I don’t need to tell you about her.” Tony pointed upward. “A perfect nickname for her.”
I played along. “Such a great nickname, it described her to a T.” I didn’t remember Aly or Tony. Maybe lost memories would resurface, if I attended the gathering at Milo’s. Confused thoughts filled my brain.
My curiosity got the best of me. So to try to put this puzzle together I went to Milo’s. My story to explain why I’d been out of touch was the extensive business travel up east, which led me to setting up a permanent residence in Baltimore.
When I showed up at Milo’s, people greeted me like a reunion. Everyone knew my name, I knew no one, but I acted like they were long lost childhood friends. My senses were on high alert listening for names so I could play my part. Stories about escapades from our past brought laughter and smiles to our faces. Mine included. Not because I remembered, only that I could relate. I made mental notes placing names with faces and events.
Nothing triggered a memory for me, even the ski weekend we all spent in Taos. Aly’s brother, Chad, talked with me, about her moving to Taos after that weekend. “She lived in a tiny house just outside Angel Fire ski resort after you two split.” He looked over at me and said. “You and Aly were a great couple. None of us understood what happened.”
I looked around at the others. “Sometimes there isn’t one answer.”
Chad picked up his beer and took a swig. “You and Aly were alike in that way. You were both secretive about what happened, but neither of you blamed the other.”
“What’s your point?”
“The point is she died and you weren’t here.”
“It haunts me daily. It was too late when I found out. We hadn’t talked in several months. Our lives were on different paths.”
“That’s true.” Chad nodded. ”Aly found her passion going into a small business to connect with people. She was getting ready to open a cat cafĂ© called Aly Cats. Serving tea, sandwiches and specialty wines from local vineyards. She hadn’t even opened yet and already talked about plans to expand.”
“I know it was an accident but no one’s told me exactly what happened.”
“No one saw what happened, so we aren’t exactly sure.” Chad continued. “The police said the avalanche was triggered by an exploding propane tank. Her tiny house was buried instantly.”
“That seems like a freak accident.”
“The crazy thing is they found a second body in her house. DNA didn’t reveal anything about the mysterious person and no one recognized him.”
“Maybe she had a mystery lover. Could be nothing more than that.”
Although I had no memory of ever knowing them, I spent the rest of the evening chatting with old friends. I left early as it was becoming difficult to keep up this game of charade.
That night when I lay my head on the pillow, my mind was whirling with crazy scenarios of the stories about Aly.
* * *
The next morning I woke feeling groggy and decided to walk down to the coffee shop to get an espresso. I needed a shot of caffeine. As I turned to head over to a booth, I saw Chad, so I walked over to say hi.
“Chad, I wanted to apologize for not being around when Aly died.”
He scratched his chin and cocked his head. “How did you know Aly?”
“What? I was with you last night at Milo’s. “
Still confused, he said. “I’m sorry. You must have mistaken me for someone else.”
“We talked about her tragic accident.” I gave Chad a puzzled look.
“Accident? You mean her being murdered but her boyfriend John.“
“What? No! Wasn’t it an avalanche that buried her in her house?”
“There was an avalanche that John started. He exploded a propane tank, but Aly was already dead. The avalanche killed John . . . karma.”